Saturday, April 24, 2010
The "Down Low"
My eyebrows kind of rose when I read about what being on the “Down Low” meant. I found it so unheard of to technically be gay, but consider yourself not to be due to your particular culture’s views. It is one thing to not “come out of the closet” or seemingly acknowledge to others that you are gay, but it is another to deny to yourself that you actually are gay and refuse to put the label of being “gay” on it even if you simply plan to keep it to yourself.
I definitely agree that “looking black enough” equates to “looking masculine, tough, and “straight.” It seems as though a black man will not admit to being gay, because there is such a strong focus on masculinity, and it is viewed as though gayness and masculinity cannot go hand in hand with each other. This made me think back to class, when we talked about the idea of “doing gender,” that gender is not something that you are, it is something that you do. These technically gay men on the “Down Low,” are not gay, that they are masculine and just like to have a good time.
I find it interesting that the black culture finds the “Down Low” label to be a separation from white, gay culture. In particular, I like the response that followed Denizet-Lewis’s question of the difference between being on the “Down Low” and being in the closet, stating that, “Being on the DL is about having fun, being who you are, but keeping your business to yourself. The closet isn’t fun. In the closet, you’re lonely.” This example definitely shows that people have their own ideas about gender in their particular culture, and they find their black culture’s view on it different than the white culture’s view of gayness. The statement that really expressed the black culture’s belief on gayness reads, “It’s not like if you’re black and gay, because then it’s like you’ve let down the whole black community, black women, black history, black pride.” This statement reads as though being gay is a bad thing, and that the black community cannot take another blow to its ego.
I felt that it was a very logical idea that the black community is “simply too homophobic and views homosexuality as a curse against a race with too many strikes against it; whereas, the white community is more accepting of its sexual minorities, leading to fewer double lives, less shame, and less unsafe sex.” I also thought that the concept of gay men not admitting that they are gay because they need their family because of economic reasons and racism in particular was a very valid excuse. It was really sad to think about how black, gay men can choose to be discriminated against at home for their sexuality or discriminated somewhere else for their skin color, if they do choose to share with others that they are gay. It is not right that society is like this, and people should be able to express their sexuality no matter what the color of their skin may happen to be.
Because this article discussed the AIDS epidemic, I was thinking about healthcare, and I noticed a particular quote that seemed to express a concept dominant to the black culture, “Black people trust the church. We don’t trust health care. We don’t trust doctors and nurses, but we trust the church. So when the church says, ‘Get tested,’ when the church says, ‘Take your medicine,’ people will do it.” This particularly reminded me about when we discussed in class how institutions interact and why the health disparities among races exist. I connected this to this particular quote from the article, because if minority representation among doctors and other care positions can be increased in the health care field and facilities, black minorities may feel more comfortable getting help. Yes, the black community should be able to trust the church, but they should be able to trust health care as well.
Friday, April 23, 2010
Music
Rap music is by far the most popular genre in the young adult age group but its lyrics are becoming more and more controversial. In a time when all violence is blamed on video games, media, and movies, song lyrics are being heavily scrutinized. The documentary we watched in class give a very different insight for me on how the artists themselves view the music they produce.
The big question is how much do song lyrics really matter? When someone in a song degrades a woman and talks about her as an object, should we take offense to that? Some of the women interviewed about song lyrics calling women “bitches and hoes” were not offended, and stated “they aren’t talking about me.” I think that artists should be responsible for the words they spit and insulting and demeaning lyrics shouldn’t be tolerated. Personally, I think that certain lyrics go over the top and should make people upset. However, as stated by some of the young artists, walking into a label and talking about the hardships of the ghetto and verbalizing positive messages are not selling. The image of being strong, manly, and worthy of street respect are the artists that get deals and in a market that expects this-artists are willing to sacrifice their lyrics to get a break. As well, labels put out catchy music and tend to slide in derogatory statements in between the choruses which distract many from truly hearing what they are listening to. The only way to get around this is to find music underground and break from the mainstreams but this is much more time consuming.
The most shocking thing I think in the documentary was when Byron asked the record label if they thought the music they produced further upheld black stereotypes and he failed to comment. Pretty much he said, “Yeah the depictions of black men with drugs, money, and violent imagery allow middle class white kids further reason to distrust the young black population.” There is also discrepancy as to how “black” a lot of these rap artists are. First off, they say they are from the ghetto and get shot at, but they have millions of dollars and do not have to live that way. I find it hard to believe half of the things said in rap lyrics, especially from wealthy artists. Lyrically the use of certain slangs and swear words, especially like “niggaz,” are heavily overused and incredibly insulting. Usually, the more frequent use of a word, the more desensitized we become to it, but these words have not lost their meaning. The overuse of said words makes people believe they are okay to use in everyday language with their friends and when talking to others, yet this is not the case. Additionally, the double standard of race and slang is ridiculous. If the words “bitch, nigga, and hoe” are said within your race group it appears to be accepted, but as soon as another race uses them a word war erupts. If words like that are not okay, and they are offensive, then no one should be using them in such casual terms. The overuse of swear words gives attempts at power through intimidation, but in reality just make people sound stupid.
Other types of music are not exempt either, which makes me really question what I put on my ipod. By buying catchy music, and mainstream songs I am supporting the lyrics in that music whether I do or not. I want the music that I listen to, to represent my beliefs and attitudes which means I need to start choosing my songs differently.
Saturday, April 17, 2010
For love or money?
This past week in class we were talking about marriage and the diversity that has started to come along with it. Some classmates had explained that within their communities and friend's families, same race and ethnicity was important with marriage, whereas in a community that I grew up in there was not a lot of diversity and it made no difference who was dating who. I found it rather interesting how complicated marriage has became within our society and I wonder if it matters to marry for love anymore.
In the article, “American's Have a Different Attitude” it has showed that many of the families want their daughters to marry within the same ethnicity, and that they allow the men to go around choose whoever they want. The parents wanted to make sure that the girls upheld the name. To me I believed that it should be the girl's decision about who she chooses to marry. Who says that this arranged marriage is going to work out and that it is truly what's best for the family? No one can see into the future and I firmly believe that it should be the choice of the girl. Some girls had commented on the fact that their parent's voices were in the back of their head, and that they were afraid the parents would stop communication with them. I feel very bad for people in that situation, they want to be happy, but they are giving up their happiness for their parents. I know from personal experience that my old roomate was told to take her career as far as possible, but she went on to tell me that when her parents had found her a husband she was to get married and become a stay at home mom, and she could never tell her parents that she was dating someone. I felt so bad that she wasn't able to do what she wanted in life, and that she had to put all her wants and needs aside just to make them happy.
On the other hand, there are some people that choose to marry within their ethnicity and believe that the real women are those who are from their same ehtnicity. For example in the article, “Yellow Fever,” the author talks about how some of her boyfriends or even the white men that were at first interested in her, dumped her to find a girl who was more Japenese. Many men wanted a geisha to take care of them and one who was adventourous, and many felt that American women were too independent. My first thought was, what is this the 1910's? Women no longer are stay at home wives, however there are still some women who believe that that is how they can move up in the world, by being what men want. The article goes on to say that these ideal women do what men want and that many of them are middle age white men. It makes me uncomfortable knowning that there are men still out there that want women to only take care of them.
A last topic that I believe was really interesing involving marriage is the Exchange Hypothesis, and this stated that people are willing to give up racial status for economic status. I feel like this is a big contradiction from everything that I had just talk about, dealing with people who want to marry someone from their own race and ehtnicity. Some people in the class found it hard that there are people out there who marry just for money, or to move up in the social ladder. I can't get the thought out of my mind that no one wants to be just happy and in love anymore, and that all that has become important is power and fame. Whatever happened to working as hard as you can and at the end of the day you should just be happy with your life? I feel that we should reevalute the important of things and life and see that love and happiness comes first, then success and money comes later.
"Bien Cuidada"
The concept of there being a greater “cultural acceptance” of being overweight within Hispanic communities wasn’t as big of a shock to me as I had imagined. When I thought about it, it really made a lot of sense. Different cultures are more or less accepting of particular things, such as appearances and actions, compared to other cultures. In the Hispanic culture, curviness is embraced.
Haubegger also linked the curviness and being technically “overweight” to food and what exactly is consumed among the particular culture. The wording of, “You feed people you care for, and so if you’re well cared for, bien cuidada, you have been well fed” was kind of a stretch for me. Yes, I understand what Haubegger is saying, that it is a part of the Latino culture, but I feel as though caring for people can be shown in a different way, rather than through the use of the foods particular to the culture. I wouldn’t really be as affected by the idea of this statement had the issue of food leading to being overweight not been such a huge factor. I value my health, and I believe that if you care about someone, you should want them to live a healthy life, and it seems as though being well fed by being “bien cuidada” may be the most accepted in the Latino culture, but in the scheme of things, it is harming your physical well being.
Even though I disagree with the basis of caring for people by making sure they are “bien cuidada,” I am pleased to hear that the Latino culture is more accepting of body shapes than other cultures. It really is a shame that in 2010, discrimination seems to exist even based upon peoples’ weight and body shape. It is sad that people do not always accept others as they should, and it sometimes it seems as if people cannot put themselves in another person’s shoes, and see life from that person’s perspective. I feel as though in order to really try to understand someone, you need to look at life from their point of view, and unless this happens, inequality will continue to exist, whether it is based upon race, age, class, gender, or even weight.
Friday, April 16, 2010
"He looks Jewish..."
The lecture we had recently on interracial relationship and its statistics, has given me some good ideas on how and why my ideas differ so much from my parents. The stats of intermarriage differ by Group, Gender, Educations, and Geography and in those groups I already see the differences between my parents and me. Educationally, my parents finished high school and had no further education. The high school included the same people they had been going to school with since pre-school and so the lack of diversity and expending cultural knowledge is obvious there. Similarly, geography has kept them isolated their whole lives also limiting the amount of cultural difference they experience. I remember my dad telling me about how he did not see an African American person until he arrived at the U.S airport when he was 27. This goes hand in hand with what we learned weeks ago in how ones neighborhood has the ability to create boundaries and exclude them from learning about differences that exist in the world when it comes to culture and race.
Often times when I would argue with my dad, I would be frustrated because his opinions were so socially constructed and, to me, evidently incorrect. Sometimes his comments include things such as “Oh he looks Jewish,” or “What do you expect, he’s black.” I was able to relate these concepts to the theories we learned against Physiognomy, something that is still commonly believed in Poland. The Symbolic Integrationist Theory matches perfectly with the socially constructed stereotypes that my parents have. In my opinion, the stereotypes are not just because they were exposed to little diversity, but rather the symbols and labels that were present in small non-diverse community they grew up in. They had no way of disproving those labels because they were never gotten the opportunity to prove some of those labels as incorrect. For example, if they would have had the opportunity to socialize with an African American, they would have been able to disprove the label that all African Americans are lazy. Thankfully, I was able to get an opportunity to be a part of more diverse culture. When I came to college I quickly made friends with a variety of people, many of which were culturally and racially diverse. I loved this opportunity because it was a very large learning experience.
One of the most educational experiences I had was when I started dating a boy that was Jewish. Of course never having had that I found myself questioning, is this ok? Even though I knew what my parents would say, I wanted to educate myself about the Jewish culture and see how people of that culture and religion felt about interfaith relationships. It took a while for my boyfriend and I to talk about this issue because, as we later discovered, both of us felt scared of being unaccepted. I am catholic so when it came to be Christmas time I slowly started talking about religious aspects of Christmas which to say the least made very awkward conversation. One night I asked him jokingly what he wanted for Christmas, and he corrected me and said “you mean Hanukah?” It was then that I found out a lot of his views on interfaith relationships which helped me form some opinions. He told me about how against his parents were about his older brother marrying a Christian girl, but how after it happened they learned to accept it and how now they celebrate Hanukah and Christmas. This matched perfectly with the discussion we had about the consequences of interracial marriage. It was apparent that his brother’s interfaith marriage brought positive consequences to his family, and not only made the distinction between the two religions less important in their everyday lives, but also caused a reduction in the discrimination and stereotypes they held before. Now I wonder if my parents would react the same way, or if the amount of time they spend developing and holding certain stereotypes affects whether they are able to be broken.
Criminal Justice and Races
The United States statistically has the highest incarceration rates across the globe. Yet, when the divisions between races are exposed, there are large differences. As a country, racial inequalities need to be addressed differently.
Unfortunately, the law benefits the wealthy and those who can afford good lawyers. White people charged with crimes tend to serve shorter sentences, are punished less, and are often let off in exchange for community service. However, when we look at those who are in jail, it is mainly young black males. As stated previously, police officers are commended for "arresting criminals" and "helping win the war on drugs." This essentially means, go to the inner city and catch as many black males for drugs as possible. The incarceration rates for black males disproportionally sky rocketed in comparison to those of whites.
However, white stereotypes of black males are non-involved fathers, drug abusers, and overall "bad" people. Yet, when 40% of the young black males in the United States are either in jail, on probation, or some other type of watch program, how are they ever given a chance? The repetitive cycle of locking up young black males leads to a further decrease in education and puts them at a disadvantage in the job market. This also leads to a high unemployment rate within the black community. Crime rates also do not go down as a result of being in prison. After being locked up for 10 years and you have no money, a job, a house, and your family does not want anything to do with you- what are the options? Also 75% of people who are incarcerated are classified as having anti-social personality disorder which in turn basically states a general lack of concern for themselves, others, or the consequence of the law. Consequently many of those incarcerated once, will be again. Additionally, this leads to the divisions within the black population in relation to "street" and "decent" origins. When you live life in the inner city and associate police as useless, actions will reflect this. As well, most black people do not fear prison; in fact, it is a signature sign of toughness as stated in the readings.
White people are just as, or more likely to do drugs in comparison to black people but they are generally more discrete about it. White people tend to make deals within a suburban home where no one really knows about it. As well, because a lot of middle class whites smoke marijuana, the laws based around it are becoming less strict. Another reason for such high drugs abuse rates in white is the large social demands set upon them to succeed. Many white people are depressed from these demands and find drugs and alcohol’s effects to be their way out. It is even known that doctors use things like speed to maintain attention and focus during long surgeries. This "unfairness" leads to further turmoil within the inner city.
Unfortunately, I have seen the inner workings of the unfairness within the middle class. I have seen people from high school get busted for 1.5lbs of marijuana, clearly with the intent to sell, and get let off on community service and weekly drug tests. I also know someone whose house was raided by police looking for heroin, to find none, but found a bunch of marijuana and nothing happened to them. I do understand that in the grand scheme of life, marijuana is not really a direct harm to self or anyone around them, but illegal none the less. As well, I had a boyfriend in high school that got pulled over at least once a week for speeding, drifting, neons, etc and to this day I think he only has 3 speeding tickets. I do honestly believe that because all of these people were middle class white males, they were let off with slaps on the wrists.
Honestly, I think the war on drugs was one of the biggest mistakes as far as policy goes. By arresting a ton of young black males, we over filled our prison system and billions of tax dollars are spent each year to keep these people in jail. The reason so many drugs are problems, is because they are illegal. The “bad” deals that go down and things like police shootings occur because many people do fear prison and will do anything to escape. The law also doesn’t change that fact that people are going to continue to do drugs legal or not.
Additionally, prejudices based on race in the justice system also need to be addressed. Consequently of these prejudices, especially those toward black males, innocent people have been shot and killed by the police due to the suspicion of black men carrying guns. The implict association test scrambles “white and good” and “blacks and bad” as a key and then has you match the words as quickly as possible and then switch the word associations. I personally took that test in my psychology class and was a little shocked at my own subconscious beliefs in that, I wasn’t aware of them. My average time when associating “blacks and good” was higher than “whites and good.” Studies have proven that the subconscious attitudes of police officers can be manipulated by exposure and retraining the subconscious implicit associations.
The unfairness in our justice system on race based offenses is wrong and needs to be addressed immediately to save the black community from falling further.
Monday, April 5, 2010
Divisions in School
A few weeks back, class was focused primarily on what advantages are given to certain children in the school systems. Primarily it helped draw the lines of class and racial distinctions between disadvantaged youth who then fall further. The bottom line was, and is, should we divide children into “gifted and talented” programs or let them all be equivalent learners?
There has been a lot of psychology research done specifically on the development of children and how they learn that supports the idea of division. Children must be taught in their zone of proximities meaning that, in order to effectively teach children the information must not be above their understanding, or be things that have already learned. Children who are bored in school have a tough time sitting through hours of material they have already learned and spend more time socializing. Additionally, if children aren’t being challenged, they aren’t actively learning and thus are not moving forward.
However, there are social implications to dividing children which mostly hurt those who are not defined as gifted. When children are consistently told they are not as smart as other children, a mental block is formed and most children tend to believe they are not as smart. Additionally, when teacher’s expectations of children are low, statistically children perform much worse than their counterparts. This was also shown in the Riceville video clip when the children were substantially slower at the card deck when they were defined as the lower group. These divisions especially affect those who were disadvantaged from the beginning. Low SES children are generally disadvantaged in their pre-k years due to stressful family situations and lack of resources. Additionally, low SES parents are usually less educated than their middle class counterparts and thus may not understand how to teach children prior to starting school. As well, many middle class parents spend a lot of time and money placing their children in well respected day care and pre-school facilities that foster cognitive development. Competing with these prepped babies on the same level is just not feasible since their education levels are substantially different.
Yet, how can you justify not letting children thrive and succeed to their full potentials? When school systems have the resources to allow children more diverse and challenging educations, why shouldn’t they? Personally, I was divided from my math scores during the 5th grade and those followed me throughout all of high school. I know I would not be where I am unless I had been pushed along and challenged all of high school. Our gifted group was established by my middle school principle whose wife worked in an inner city Milwaukee school who wholeheartedly believed in teaching to a child’s level of understanding. She felt it wasn’t fair to the children who showed a high level of cognitive development early on to hinder their abilities. Thus, our school system was held up by the idea of challenges, success, and excellence. Our school district upheld the belief of the “gifted” and it was tested by the school board numerous times. I was given above and beyond opportunities to dissect sharks, study plate-tectonics, read college level books, participate in math competitions, and later take college level courses. I know I would not be where I am without the class divisions I faced early on in life and thank those who fought to give me those opportunities.
However, who is to say that boy who was not chosen as a “gifted” student at 10 years old, wouldn’t have excelled in the same way with the extra opportunities? How can a teacher divide 10 year olds up and say, “Sally is college bound, while Sam….Well, he might become a plumber?” Parents always say, “You can be anything you want to be,” except when you live in socialist societies like
Overall, the socioeconomic and racial status of a family defines education of young children which follows them their whole lives. Separating children and teaching to their level of understanding is crucial to effective learning in children. Children set at the lower half of their class are destined to stay there according to current approaches yet those are the children who need the most help. Funding is the largest part holding these children back as explicitly seen in both “Life on the Mississippi” and “Children of the City Invincible: Camden, New Jersey.” I believe that there should still be gifted programs that allow children to expand their knowledge and abilities but the need to bring the bottom up is a greater concern.