Monday, May 3, 2010
Falling in Love with an Image
First, one of my ex-boyfriends would always introduce me to his friends and family, and shortly after the introduction would insert a comment that I was Polish. His dad’s side of the family was Polish so when he introduced me in this manner to his family I was not too concerned. But unfortunately, the introduction did not stop there. I noticed he would often insert the fact that I was Polish to everyone he introduced me to and it started getting really annoying. I did not think it was appropriate that these strangers have this pre-conceived image of me before they knew my individual personality. When I finally spoke to him about this he was confused on why I was offended. He proceeded to comment that his older brother once dated an older Polish woman and had always advised him to marry a “Polack” because he could be assured he would be taken care of. This comment offended me tremendously because I did not consider myself a “traditional” Polish woman who was only going to clean and cook for their significant other. When I explained to him I had dreams to go to Law School and that I was not going to be whom he thought I was he got very angry that I was accusing him of believing all these stereotypes about Polish women.
Needless to say, our relationship did not pursue for much longer. I still believe he had these stereotypes instilled into his head, however I am no longer so sure it was necessarily his fault. After learning about co-opting and the impact media plays on the beliefs of individuals, I believe that might have had a large contribution to his perception. I know Polish people, women especially, are always perceived by the media as being the typical housewife. When the image of cooking and cleaning is co-opted, it condenses our culture, restricts other real aspects of our culture and ultimately gives a false image.
I often notice similar behavior from my guy friends who perceive certain sorority girls a certain way. Although these perceptions are passed off by word of mouth and rumors, it is still bothersome that they generalize large groups into one stereotype. It’s weird because I did not realize how judgmental I was until this class. I often find myself pre-disposing people I meet to a certain image and I have been trying to be more cautious of it. No one appreciated being identified as a generalization.
The Intent of Entertainment?
First, it shows the double standard that our society tends to apply. Many people in class were discussing how certain jokes are appropriate if an individual of that race/religion says them and not ok if they are about a different race/religion than their own. At first this made sense to me and its like I have always thought this “social norm” without really thinking about it. I can see how someone making fun of their own identity is funny and its typically because the jokes they choose to tell are often less offensive to individuals like themselves. For example, a white person might choose to make fun of the Caucasian race with more accepting comments than if an African American chose to make fun of whites with comments that may be less accepted. Overall, there are certain stereotypes in groups of people that are more or less accepted than others and an individual making jokes of their own group will typically chose to poke fun of the stereotypes that are more accepted.
However, when I thought more about this double standard I realized that it does not really matter whose mouth stereotypes are being made fun of from. Society has a deceiving image of certain stereotypes because they have co-opted them. Often, the same stereotypes are poked fun of while other cultural aspects of a group of people go unheard. By only allowing society to hear certain stereotypes get made fun of, the comedian is almost changing the way a society perceives that certain culture. With this thought, I do not believe that anyone has the right to choose how an entire group of people’s culture is perceived by society. I don’t think it make a difference whether the person is in that group or not, that is not a privilege anyone should have.
So these apposing ideas really confuse me. I see both sides, however, I don’t necessarily feel against comedians who use these comical methods to make people laugh. After our last lecture I have come to the conclusion that I believe it’s about the intent of the person poking fun of the stereotype. This makes sense with my first viewpoint because obviously people who are poking fun of themselves don’t intend to inflict pain or offend anyone from their own race/religion etc. Also, going along with the second viewpoint, most comedians’ sole purpose is to entertain. They are not trying to condense cultures, restrict real cultures, or give a false image of a certain culture. With that said, although comedians mean to entertain, it does not mean that they don’t also do those things unintentionally. In a discussion we had in class, I thought someone made a good point when they said an individual going to the Sarah Silverman show should go knowing what to expect, and thus should not take offense to the jokes she makes. However, if a comedian goes to speak on a talk show such as Silverman did at Cannons, people are not there to be accepting towards the jokes she makes. In this case, if the saphire of the joke is not correct people will get offended.
All in all, comedians should stick to entertaining audiences with their stereotypical jokes at their own shows where audiences are expecting it, and they’re to see it. While doing that elsewhere, I think is inappropriate.
Friday, April 30, 2010
Polysemic Images
I definitely thought the Dove advertisement was a great way to introduce polysemic images. In the past, I have mostly seen the Dove advertisements in magazines geared toward women. First of all, I think that it is very reassuring that the image consists of women representing a variety of races. Seeing as though it is a campaign for “real beauty,” I thought that a lot of the women featured in the advertisement were still fairly thin, as well as pretty. But then again, these adjectives, “thin” and “pretty,” can all be interpreted differently. What I find to be thin or pretty may not be your same definition of thin or pretty.
I found it ironic that this advertisement focused toward “real beauty” by using an image of a group of racially and physically diverse women, yet was actually promoting their product of anti aging lotion. To me, “real beauty” means that everyone will be accepted no matter what they look like, but Dove is trying to persuade the person that looks at their advertisement to purchase their product that is meant to combat the effects of aging skin. Really, how does “real beauty” translate to purchasing products in an attempt to stay looking young, rather than accepting the way we look in the first place and finding that beautiful?
My reaction to the Dove advertisement was initially a fairly positive one, but once I thought about the image I was seeing and actually analyzed it, I felt that the image itself was almost too perfect. However, I think that Dove did a reasonably good job with their advertisement. Their first and foremost goal is to make money, so they are going to try to incorporate this image of “real beauty” into their product in order to broadcast it, which is a great idea. The more you can communicate with “real” women about your product, the more likely they will be to try it. I think that even though they are using “real” women to advertise their anti aging lotion, the product will still sell. Women seek out beauty products in order to maintain their beauty, and Dove is simply trying to please their current customers as well as drum up new business. I think that Dove found a good balance between focusing on selling their product as well as connecting to “real” women.
Even discussing examples of polysemic images prove to be difficult, because there is so much meaning behind the images in the first place, and then there is meaning behind the opinions of those images. I am sure there are people that disagree with my interpretation of the Dove advertisement, but the whole point of it is to prove that images are polysemic, and no matter what, there will be endless possibilities of interpretations.
Indian Mascots
The idea of Indian mascots being controversial was something I never had even looked twice at. However, when I think about it, there are really no other “human” mascots except pirates. Indians are a very small minority population that has been stomped since the beginning of time. The woman from the video was offended because she anticipated a cartoon version of chief Illiniwek and that the costume was “too authentic” while the dance was a mockery of their culture. I never looked at these mascots as being offensive to the Indian population, but I clearly was wrong.
In recent news, collegiate North Dakota is being forced to change their mascot, the Sioux Indian. It was very striking to me that the Sioux Indians chose not to endorse the mascot and it forced the removal. The NCAA restricted them from post season play until all symbols were removed. The logo will be gone for the 2010-2011 season. Interestingly enough this came up about a week ago while I was working softball for the UW-Athletic Ticket Office when UW played North Dakota. According to my manager, their stadium had symbols on the backs of every chair, and the logo in marble on the floor of the stadium entrance. In essence, now 10 million dollars worth of logos must be removed and replaced. A debate sparked between my co-workers over whether it was justly done. The general consensus was that they should remove their mascot, which surprised me. One guy said, “If it offends an entire tribe we shouldn’t go against that.” After looking at it that way, I agree. I did not look at the Indian mascot as being offensive to a religion and culture which is to my own ignorance.
However, as stated in the video- if the Indian would have been funny and cartooned, the symbol wouldn’t be a big deal. At what point do we cross the line? Talk about intention was crucial to crossing that line, but I do not think there is a clear winner. Trying to be authentic caused actual offense but being made fun of also didn’t make them happy. On some level, keeping the tradition of a symbol is important to fans, colleges, and support but tradition can be changed to gain the same support. Any symbol can become important to a group. North Dakota has not agreed on a new symbol yet but les hope their next one can last longer.
Thursday, April 29, 2010
American Indians as a mascot
Today we watched a clip from the documentary about use of Indian caricatures as a mascot in the United States. The part of the documentary that we saw mainly concerned experience of Charlene Teters, and her struggles of trying to deliver a message that native indians should not be a mascot.
After the clip, several classmates had made their own points and experience related to the documentary. Aside from their own experiences, some had questioned validity of Teter's claims, and if I remember correctly, I presume that they had hard time understanding why Teter was offended by University of Illinois mascot, illini.
True, on the surface, Teter's reaction towards her kids responding to Illini mascot during halftime may seem too drastic. Yet however, one could not argue against Teter for having logic behind her claims.
If we were to weigh Teter, and University of Illinois representatives and their fans solely on a subject that states "Does having native indian mascots insult native americans?" It is certain that Teter's argument will be considered more rigid.
Before anything else, she is a "real" representation of what University of Illinois is represented as in basketball games; such an irony for both Teter, and the university. It is as if followers of islam is arguing against prophet Muhammad himself, to protect their own interpretation of Koran. Although such comparison may be drastic, I believe they only differ in degrees , still applicable in terms of fundamental concept. Likewise, she has more to say in the matter than the other.
If Teter had felt differently in the past, the problem may had been avoided. Teter and University of Illinois would not have collided if Teter felt University of Illinois had presented the chief in correct terms and circumstances. Again, she is the one that is being offended, and she has every right to revolt against it. Although she may not be a representative for entire native indian population, it is certain that general opinion on the matter is not much different than that of Teter.
Even more, there already exists a previous examples such as disappearance of black caricutures in market businesses. University of Illinois misinterpreted and misrepresented native indian chief, and they used this unelaborate presentation of chief for their own benefits and purposes. How does one not listen to Teter's argument?
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
The media...
I cannot recall her name, but Angela introduced female Korean comedian who stated that the problem with Asian jokes is that there is no character; what people consider funny about Asian is not certain characteristics or habits, what's considered funny is Asian itself.
Well, I could not agree more on her comment. I could learn that all the other ethnicity jokes in the United States change in time as the society progresses, but not Asian jokes in particular. The jokes are so plain and characterless.
Asian jokes are, and they will always be the same. Asian jokes have been unchanging when all the other racial jokes, Scottish for example, have been evolving from jokes about kilt to Sean Connery, and then to something else.
Also, unlike other racial jokes, Asian jokes are not even subcategorized, when "White" jokes would be divided by nation, social class, and gender. An irony is that more number of nations are categorized as being part of Asia, compared to nations and ethnicities in Europe and North America. People in the United States do not know much about Asia except for Japan and China and the media extends such ignorance.
I spent a year as a senior in the U.S. preparatory. Despite being in Michigan, where not so many Korean immigrants inhabit, there were many Korean students. Some of them lived in dormitories and some others attended from their homes nearby.
Anyways, maybe because we were mostly immature, it was common for the most students to pick on someone else because of their race or ethnicity, and my ethnicity was no exception, and from all those names that I had called upon, I could realize how ignorant they were about Asia. It was either they could not tell difference between Japan and China, or they just did not care enough.
No matter what the truth was, it was not so much of pleasant experience. I was ok with racial jokes and never were offended in anyway because such jokes were popular and it was some twisted way of students getting to know more about each other. However, it was disappointing to realize how well average Michigan teenagers were informed or educated about Asia and various nations and cultures within.
I personally approve and agree with racial jokes. I believe they deliver feelings of intimacy or interest from one race towards another, only if used in right circumstances.
With the issue of what racial joke is allowable and what is not, I only have my own boundaries, and I do not know what would be the borderline of racial jokes should be. However, with the issue of Asian jokes, it is not even necessary yet for anyone to think of what is ok and what is not ok when joking about Asian race because most people are not educated enough to think about such, and the media prolongs such tendencies of people in the United States.
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
Where Sunshine and Rainbows Don't Cut It Anymore
Lately we have been talking about media and how it implants certain images about gender, race and ethnicity. I never realized how much the media has made me believe things about certain people. I like watching Family Guy which has a lot of jokes amongst the show but I can now see how certain images that they show had given me a different persepctive on items. I at first am embaressed to say that I believe in or thought that what they were saying was true, but like stated from the Sarah Silverman article, many of the jokes that people say come from what others were thinking but are not able to say.
During class we talked about two views of media within our society. One that stuck out to me was the hypoedermic model which states that the media injects in people (beliefs and values). I truly believe that this view is correct. I feel that many parents in our country allow their children tow atch very innappropriate shows at such a young age. I remember being in high school and watching the news and hearing about a young boy around the age of eight who committed suicide and thought that he would be able to come back to life, because Kenny on South Park did all of the time. How did our society get this far into thinking that it was ok to show someone killing themselves then coming back to life, as if nothing happened? Violence use is a major problem in the United States, so wouldn't the media want to stop the use of it, and help people stay away from this terrible problem?
Maybe some people in our society do not feel that everyone will take the message that way and thus they believe it is ok to portray those things? I had asked a bunch of my friends what they thought about the South Park incident and many believed that it was the parent and the kid's fault for not knowing the difference between fake and reality. I agree that it should be the parents responsibility to tell their child what would really happen, however and eight year old in my opinion should not be watching a shoe that is made for the older age group. My question is, is it good to show an ad that has a caption saying your not a man until you have a gun, or until your serving your country and killing the enemy? Do we feel that we need to teach our men and some women to be tough and not to take crap from people? Whatever happen to being able to turn the other cheek and rise above all of the violence? As a society if we potray negative things as being good things then in the end wont all of the positive things in life be totally forgotten?
Today in class it was brought up that we take things away and present people with a new idea of the world. I wonder who benefits from this if people are not seeing how the world really is? Is it the leader of our country who decides what is the best and worst for us? To me, I thought that I could come up with things to sell to people and tell how and what to believe in, considering how easy it is for our society to be persuaded. Our world is filled with more problems than just racial jokes, it goes more indepth with education, people on welfare, crime and the economy itself. If we continue to block people from what is really going on in the world then we are doing more harm than good. It is troubling to see that a lot of people now just go with the flow and do not voice a lot of their opinions? Perhaps, it is because they do not want to turned on?