Sunday, May 9, 2010

Racist Jokes

After reading the articles “You just don’t get it, Silverman” and “How it went down” I was beyond shocked how this one word, “chink,” could cause so much controversy. The dialogue and conversation in the articles went on and on about whether or not it was an appropriate joke for Silverman to have told, and honestly, at that point, if I were Silverman I would feel like never ever telling another joke again. All of this thanks to one word. I definitely think that part of the reason it was such a huge deal was because Silverman is not Chinese. If she were Chinese I think that the audience and anyone else would not have had such a huge problem wither her saying the word. Because she is white, she does not have the “right” to say that word.

I find this extremely similar to the use of the “N-word.” A long time ago in class, we watched a video clip about a teacher referring to his students in such a fashion, insisting that it was okay because it was not only a different tense of the word, but that it was how all of the students referred to each other. First of all, he shouldn’t have been saying it to students in the first place, but if he weren’t a teacher and if here were black, I don’t think there would have been such great controversy over it. A black person is allowed to say that term, but a white person or any other person of another race does not have the “right” to do so.

It is controversies like these that make me not want to ever say a single word that directly indicates race. Many people get easily offended when it comes to the subject of race, and sometimes I find it best to avoid any mention of race at all.

One thing Silverman said that really made me think was, “Yeah, it is clearly a joke, you know, illuminating racism. It’s not a racist joke. It’s a joke about racism.” First of all, I think that all jokes can be interpreted differently. No matter what the intent, the listener forms their own interpretation, and it is their own personal opinion that decides whether or not they even thought the joke was funny in the first place. Second, I do not quite understand what Silverman means by her use of the words “illuminating racism.” Was she showing that racism is a bad thing? I don’t think so. In her joke she implied that the word “chink” was inappropriate, but yet her quote did not make me learn a lesson about racism. Third, I would like to say that I would like to have her explain the difference between a racist joke and a joke about racism. They may seem like two totally different things to her, but this is because of the way she interprets them. When the public is interpreting her jokes, they form their own beliefs, and don’t always understand the joke the way she sees it. For this reason, I think that people who say racist jokes or “jokes about racism” should be very cautious about what they say about other races.

Mascots and Offense

Regarding the film “In Whose Honor” about Native American mascots, I was shocked how emotional the main woman was about seeing the Native American mascot at a basketball game. Personally, I think she was being a little overdramatic with her insistence that things that she was taught to respect were being mimicked for entertainment purposes. Yes, it is true that entertainment was the goal, but the intent was not to offend anyone. I think she was so emotional about the whole thing because she is so connected to her heritage and culture. I have a friend that is part Native American and she goes to Florida State University, whose mascot is the Seminoles, and she finds no offense to it whatsoever. The fact that the mascot is the Seminoles was not a deciding factor when applying to the school, or when deciding to attend. But then again, she is not extremely involved in her Native American heritage like the woman from the film was.

I think that really there isn’t a huge reason to change these mascots. But if it is going to prove to be more trouble than it is worth, the school might as well change them. I think that some people will be offended no matter what the mascot is changed to. You can never please everyone. In cases like these, I feel that it is important for those who feel offended to think about the intent of the mascot. If the mascot was chosen to represent an authority figure that commands respect, then shouldn’t people be proud? Because I don’t have an opposition or direct cultural connection to these mascots, I find it hard to understand why this huge controversy exists.

The idea of Native Americans being mimicked and portrayed out of tradition brings up a topic which we discussed earlier in class, Halloween costumes. A few people in class seemed very opposed to dressing up like Native Americans. Personally, I find nothing wrong with this. One of the things I dressed up as this past Halloween was a cowgirl. I ask, am I offending cowboys in the west when I wear this outfit? Will I really offend people if I decide to be a Native American next Halloween? What if, my eight year old sister just loves Pocahontas, a Disney character, and wants to be her for Halloween. Is that just as offensive? What if she decides to be Jasmine, a Disney princess, who is Middle Eastern, will she offend people from the Middle East? If she is Mulan, will she offend the Chinese? Where and how do we decide what is offensive or acceptable? I feel that because everyone finds different things offensive, it is impossible to get rid of all mascots that people find offensive. It is impossible to simply draw the line that defines what you can do that is acceptable and what is offensive. It is going to be different in every case, under every circumstance. No matter what, to some extent, there will be controversy.

Segregated/Integrated Proms

I thought the documentary “Prom Night in Mississippi” was so eye-opening. The main reason I was so shocked by the town divided by race, was because even though I am from a town that is dominantly white, I don’t feel like there are people that are totally anti-black or other minorities like some of the white parents in the video were. In my opinion, the idea of segregated proms, especially still today, is one of the stupidest things I have ever heard. The United States has a legal document entitled the Bill of Rights, explaining what rights people are entitled to, and then some white parents think that their white children should not attend a dance with black children. Ridiculous. It is ideas such as these that I truly do not understand.

If anything, the only thing I can even slightly attribute their reasoning to is to having grown up in a past generation. It seems like past generations are definitely a lot less accepting of many things, race especially. I had thought that the majority of people from my generation were very accepting of all races, but the one girl in particular from the documentary that claimed to be threatened by a black girl proved that racist parents still have the ability to instill their same views into their children. If anything, I think this is sad. I feel bad for the girl, since most likely she will always view race in such a way, and she will never get it. She will never get it through her head that all people are equal. Personally, I just cannot fathom not understanding that. Growing up, I never thought I was better than anyone for being white, if I even thought anything at all, it was simply that my skin was not the same color, and that made us look different. End of story. I feel like you have to be extremely selfish to not realize that everyone has thoughts, and feelings, and people are people. Their skin color does not make them any less human.

Pertaining to the interracial couples that attended the integrated prom, I was shocked when the one white girl’s dad said that he hopes that she and her (black) boyfriend go off to different colleges and grow apart. I felt like this was such an incredibly sad thing for a parent to say. No matter what, a parent should want not only what is in the best interest for their child, but also what makes them happy. It is preposterous for her father to think that it is best for them to slowly “grow apart” simply because he does not like the fact that his daughter is dating a black boy. If anything, I would at least like to give him credit for acknowledging that it is a selfish thing for him to say. It is still a wonder how someone realizes they are being racist, but feels no need to change their ways or beliefs. All in all, I am glad that the integrated prom was a success, saddened that a white prom was still held, and I hope that the integrated prom is still held at the Mississippi school.

Saturday, May 8, 2010

Derogatory Terms

In response to the question, “Do you think women should be offended by words like “bitch and ho,” I would say yes, women SHOULD be offended by these derogatory terms. However, if you were to ask me “ARE women offended by words like “bitch and ho,” I would say no, they are not. At least in my generation, in the culture I have been brought up in, these words mean little, if anything. Yes, people go, “Oh, she is such a bitch; she did such and such…” But at the same time, girls will say things like, “Bitch, we need to go shopping this weekend. Text me.” It is like one of those words that loses its meaning over time. If someone from my mom’s generation were to be called a bitch or ho, I think it would mean a lot more, because that generation still associates those terms with the bad meaning they are really supposed to have. Differences between generations and their views on things really are shocking.

I feel that derogatory words such as bitch and ho are similar to someone saying, “That’s gay” or “That’s retarded.” Because these words have been so overused, and used out of context, the meaning does not mean what it used to mean once upon a time. I think that a lot of my generation uses vocabulary that older generations find offensive, and this is because they still connect a meaning with these terms. In my generation, these terms do not mean what they used to, so we tend to not get offended as would be expected.

The majority of my friends do use the words bitch and ho, sometimes in a mean way, sometimes in a nice way. It sounds funny to call someone a bitch or ho “in a nice way,” but the terms can almost be used to address other girls today. When you think about it like that, it is almost like a man calling a woman “his bitch.” This kind of situation brings up the concept of female objectification. The idea that women are eye-candy, and worthless, simply sex objects definitely has a connection with these derogatory terms. Until you think of it like that, it doesn’t seem like a big deal at all, but when a man seems to own a woman like that, it seems like there is a problem.

Then again, if I think about relationships and the whole boyfriend girlfriend thing, I think that people kind of put a label on their partner. A man may introduce his girlfriend to his friends and say, “This is MY girlfriend so and so…” and a woman would probably introduce her boyfriend the same way. It is just strange to think how when referring to relationships, it is almost in a possessive sense, as in someone belonging to someone else. When I think of it like that, I think that it is the girl that belongs to the guy, she is his. That is where “his bitch” comes into play. Even though society may view the words bitch and ho, as well as other derogatory terms, in this sense, I think that these terms should be considered offensive. Even though their meaning may not be as strong as it once was, the words still have that underlying meaning.

Hip-Hop and Rap

I thought that the film “Hip-Hop: Beyond Beats and Rhymes” was very eye opening. I am from the Milwaukee suburbs, I went to an almost all white school, and the majority of people my age definitely listened to music stations like 103.7 Kiss Fm, basically all hip-hop and rap music. Hearing that 70% of hip-hop listeners are white males came as a slight shock to me. I expected the percentage to be high, but I thought it would have been a little more balanced in comparison to the number of black male hip-hop listeners.

Personally, I really like hip-hop and rap types of music. At school dances, that is what we always listened to. When I would go to clubs in Milwaukee, that is exactly the kind of music that would be playing. I feel like hip-hop and rap is the music of the current generation. However, this definitely does not prove true for my mom’s generation. If we are driving in the car and I turn on hip-hop or rap she immediately changes it. She insists that she “can’t even understand what they are saying, so she is not listening to it.” In contrast, my dad doesn’t mind at all when I play music like that, in fact I think he thinks it is funny, because he often raps along and acts all thug, when in reality, he is a very Italian white guy. Most of all he just likes to give me a good laugh, but it is reassuring that he isn’t so harsh toward what I like to listen to.

When Fat Joe said, “Everybody wants to be hard,” I totally agree. Guys want to seem tough and powerful, not necessarily like a total hard-ass, but definitely cool. I don’t believe that this applies to females too, but I do have a girl friend that lived in Atlanta, Georgia for a few years, and she is white, but she acts pretty “ghetto.” And by ghetto I mean that she acts like she is a total thug, which is often expressed by her vocabulary. I think that living in Atlanta gave her this desire to act in such a manner, and she also wears clothes that are typically advertised toward black women, such as Apple Bottom, Ecko Red, and Baby Phat. By wearing these clothing brands, it is her way of acting ghetto. Back to guys wanting to be “hard,” I think that the tough front commands respect, and every guy wants to be respected, so that is what is so appealing about being “hard.” Giving off a rough and tough persona is like saying, “Don’t mess with me,” and shows a dominating nature.

I think that music made by black artists represents a different culture. Until you actually sit down and listen to the lyrics, or watch the music video, you may not totally understand what they are singing about. Yes, I understand that these lyrics may exaggerate at times or not represent a real life occurrence, but there are definitely rappers that rap about their life, such as Lil’ Wayne. I believe that music can be really eye opening to other cultures and that it gives people a feeling or sense of connection to other people. Music always has a deeper meaning, and it should be enjoyed and shared with others. Even though past generations may not view hip-hop and rap in the same light that my generation does, we can still embrace it.

Attitudes toward Sexuality

Regarding “Americans Have a Different Attitude,” I thought there were a lot of generalizations about Americans. In particular, I thought the quote from the Filipina immigrant mother referring to sex and going out with men before marriage, “And I don’t like it to happen to my daughters as if they have no values. I don’t like them to grow up that way, like American girls” was almost funny. She generalized an entire country of girls. I understand that her being Catholic affects her beliefs about sex before marriage, but the going out with men before marriage part is absurd. Personally, I don’t understand how a woman can find a man they are going to date or even figure out what kind of man they want to marry unless they date first to see what they want in a relationship. Yes, I agree that many, if not most, “American girls” date and go out with men before marriage, but all American girls do not have sex before marriage. The way she described American girls made it seem like they are awful people for having relationships with the opposite sex before marriage.

The quote from the second generation Filipina daughter, “I found that a lot of the Asian American friends of mine, we don’t date like White girls date. We don’t sleep around like White girls do” was yet another generalization toward “White girls.” Reading this quote almost made me want to laugh, because that is a ridiculous thought, that this entire group of White girls sleeps around. So not true. But I guess that is the way generalizations about certain groups of people work. People form views and opinions about groups of people and assume everyone of that color or place fits into that particular assumption or category.

I was very intrigued by the idea of the “conceptualization of white women as sexually immoral.” The Filipina view of American women lacking morals makes Filipinas seem perfect and always holding strong morals. The difference between these two groups seems to be like a competition about which is better, defined by who has the more valuable morals. I think that the interpretation by others of white women being sexually immoral may have been influenced by the media. I feel that especially in television shows aired on VH1 and MTV where there are too many reality shows to count, many of which feature white girls who live the party life. I am white, and when I see shows such as these, I think little if anything of it. I know that not all white women act in a manner similar to the one portrayed on television. The goal of television is to increase viewers and make money. Television show companies are going to air what makes them money, and if it is a show about girl drama and sex, then that is what people will make their assumptions on.

Overall, I feel that no matter what, everyone is going to form their own opinions about other cultures and ways of life. Until you walk in each and every one of these person’s shoes and see life from their perspective, you won’t truly understand the society in which people have grown up. When society is nonchalant about sexuality, people grow up to feel that way about it, nonchalant. Unless importance is placed on something, society will not show it the same respect that it may deserve.

Friday, May 7, 2010

Notes on social movement


I was always skeptical about social movement; of all the moments in recent history, I could not recall one which social movement functioned as a major turning point. I do admit that such view is rather extreme, jumping on conclusion, but it seems so true, but however, I do not completely distrust the idea.

Rather, I see social movement as antinomic, unfruitful mass action, which occur after failures of all the other possible alternatives. In uncultured terms, I interpret social movement as "squirming" of people; metaphorically, it is an act of defeated soldiers holding a castle after numerous retreats from invading enemy. Social movement is a "last resort," a final resistance against social phenomena that threaten well-beings of the society. It may fail, and does so in most cases, but its meanings and importance should not be degraded.

In recent decade, "candle light demonstration" became extremely popular in Korean societies. it is peaceful demonstration marked by candle holding demonstrators, and it has been the most popular form of demonstration in Korea for a decade. I remember reading an news article that estimates more than 30% of university students having an experience of attending candle light demonstration.

At first, the popularity of the demonstration was upheld as an icon of Korean democracy. People really believed in it. For a decade people had protested against numerous national cases. However, when I really think about its effectiveness, I am skeptical of the demonstration. candle light demonstration has been the most popular form of social movement in South Korea, but it had never really successfully altered the decisions of the government. The U.S. had gained what they wanted out of FTA deals, Korean version of patriot act was passed, new media law was enacted, and now four major Korean broadcasting stations are ran by people close to the current president. What had countless demonstrations had accomplished was only letting the government know how strongly people are opposed to the current president.

During the lecture, Angela had lectured about how social movement take in place, but I couldn't grasp on requisites of successful social movement. I know what I seek to find may not exist, and even if such exist, it would be different for different situations. I guess what I really seek to find is more cases of successful social movements besides the one by Cesar Chavez. I might be ignorant for saying such, but I think the growth and evolution of social movements have failed to keep up with today's fast-evolving economy and culture.